Aslam

general Sign in to save

If a man vows to do something when he is not in full control of his feelings, does he have to offer expiation, and what is it?

Praise be to Allah.If a person vows to do something and does not do it, then he has to

offer kafaarat al-yameen

(expiation for not fulfilling a vow). For example, if he says, “By Allaah,

I will speak to So and so” or “By Allaah, I will visit him” or “By Allaah

I will pray such and such”, and so on, then he does not do what he vowed

to do, in this case he has to offer kafaarat

al-yameen, if he was of sound mind and knew what he was saying.

But if his anger was so intense that he was not really aware, then the

vow is not binding, because it is essential that he is aware of what

he is saying. So if his anger was so intense that it made him unaware

of what he was saying, and he was out of control, then in this case

he does not have to offer kafaarah,

like one who is insane, feeble-minded or asleep.

He can forego doing what he vowed to do, if he thinks that

that is in his best interests, and he can offer expiation for his vow,

because the Prophet (peace and

blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “If you make a vow, then you

see that doing something else is better than that, offer expiation for

your vow and do that which is better.” (Saheeh – agreed upon).

So if he vowed not to visit someone, then he sees that

it is better to visit him, he should visit him and offer expiation for

his vow, and so on.

It does not matter whether he offers the expiation before

or after doing the alternative action.

And Allaah is the sources of strength.

Source: IslamQA (Sheikh Muhammed Salih Al-Munajjid)
← Previous All Questions Next →